We insist that ours is a government of laws, not men, but it is striking how often large historical forces pivot on something so unpredictable as the continued good health of a politician.
Michael BeschlossRead
American political scions evoke a central contradiction in our thinking. We believe - or say we do - in nurture, not nature. Yet we are comforted by the aristocratic notion that leadership might run in the bloodlines.
Interpretation
What this quote means
This quote reflects the tension between the belief in nurturing leadership qualities and the comforting idea that such traits are inherited.
Michael Beschloss highlights a fundamental contradiction in how we view leadership: on one hand, society promotes the belief that leadership can be cultivated through upbringing and experience (nurture), while on the other hand, there exists a comforting notion rooted in aristocracy that suggests leadership qualities are inherently passed down through genetics (nature). This duality reveals our conflicting attitudes towards what constitutes effective leadership and raises questions about the true sources of power and influence.
Themes
LeadershipNurtureNatureAristocracyPowerHeritage
In practice
Example use cases
During a lecture on leadership development, this quote can be used to provoke discussion about the influences of upbringing versus inherent traits.
More from Michael Beschloss
All quotes →Similar quotes
Perhaps, therefore, it is odd that if there is any one phrase that is guaranteed to set me off it's when someone says to me, 'OK, fine. You're the boss!' What irks me is that in 90% of such instances what that person is really saying is, 'OK, then, I don't agree with you, but I'll roll over and do it because you're telling me to. But if it doesn't work out I'll be the first to remind everyone that it wasn't my idea.'
Richard BransonRead
Think well before selecting your leader, and when you have selected him, follow him. But in case you find his policy detrimental to your interests, kick him out.
Muhammad Ali JinnahRead
As a director, you're a bit of a dictator. But I feel that you're a better director if you're open to other people's ideas. It means that it's tougher: you have to be in a choosing process; you have to put the ego aside. As long as everybody's aiming in the same direction... I'm open to my main partners in the film crew.
Denis VilleneuveRead
The team with the best players usually does win - this is why you need to invest the majority of your time and energy in developing your people.
Jack WelchRead
It was better for me when I was joined at the court by a second woman. When I was there alone, there was too much media focus on the one woman, and the minute we got another woman, that changed.
Sandra Day O'ConnorRead
Sometimes strident, often tender, never afraid and seldom without humour, Desmond Tutu's voice will always be the voice of the voiceless.
Nelson MandelaRead