Explanations are such cheap poetry.
Stephen KingRead
To the extent that the judicial profession becomes the daily routine of deciding cases on the most secure precedents and the narrowest grounds available, the judicial mind atrophies and its perspective shrinks.
Interpretation
What this quote means
The quote warns against relying solely on established precedents in judicial decision-making, suggesting it limits critical thinking.
Irving Kaufman highlights the danger of judges sticking strictly to precedents and narrow interpretations when making decisions. He argues that such an approach can lead to a stagnant judicial mindset, which fails to consider the broader implications and justice of each case. This reliance on past rulings can ultimately diminish the quality of legal reasoning and the effectiveness of the judiciary in addressing contemporary issues.
Themes
Judicial ProfessionPrecedentsJudicial MindCritical ThinkingJustice
In practice
Example use cases
During a legal seminar discussing the importance of adaptability in law.
Similar quotes
A prince never lacks legitimate reasons to break his promise.
Niccolo MachiavelliRead
The problem that faces us is the problem of awakening. What we lack is not an ideology or doctrine that will save the world. What we lack is mindfulness of what we are, of what our situation really is. We need to wake up in order to rediscover our human sovereignty. We are riding a horse that is running out of control. The way of salvation is a new culture in which human beings are encouraged to rediscover their deepest nature.
Nhat HanhRead
When men abandon reason, physical force becomes their only means of dealing with one another and of settling disagreements.
Ayn RandRead
I am a spy in the house of me. I report back from the front lines of the battle that is me. I am somewhat nonplused by the event that is my life.
Carrie FisherRead
The fear of punishment, the desire of reward, the sense of duty, are all useful arguments, in their way, to persuade people to holiness. But they are all weak and powerless, until a person loves Christ.
J. C. RyleRead