The law itself is on trial quite as much as the cause which is to be decided.
Harlan F. StoneRead
If a juror feels that the statute involved in any criminal offence is unfair, or that it infringes upon the defendant's natural god-given unalienable or constitutional rights, then it is his duty to affirm that the offending statute is really no law at all and that the violation of it is no crime at all, for no one is bound to obey an unjust law.
Interpretation
What this quote means
This quote emphasizes the moral responsibility of individuals to reject unjust laws.
Harlan F. Stone's quote underscores the principle that individuals have a duty to question and disobey laws that they believe are unfair or violate fundamental rights. It suggests that the legitimacy of any law depends on its adherence to justice and the rights of individuals, and that obeying unjust laws is not only unnecessary but also immoral.
Themes
Unjust LawRightsMoralityJurorDuty
In practice
Example use cases
In a discussion about civil disobedience during a law class.
More from Harlan F. Stone
All quotes βSimilar quotes
Truth be told, John said, the one thing in this world I want more than anything else is a great big crowbar, to jimmy myself open and take whatever creature that's sitting inside and shake it clean like a rug and then rinse it in a cold, clear lake like up in Oregon, and then I want to put it under the sun to let it heal and dry and grow and sit and come to consciousness again with a clear and quiet mind.
Douglas CouplandRead
That which you do not bring to consciousness comes to you as your Fate, that which you do bring to consciousness, whether it was what you thought you wanted or not, is your destiny.
Carl JungRead
For what's the point of breeding children, if each generation does not improve on what went before.
Hilary MantelRead
The United States was founded on the idea that all people are endowed with inalienable rights, and that principle has allowed us to work to perfect our union at home while standing as a beacon of hope to the world. Today, that principle is embodied in agreements Americans helped forge - the Universal Declaration of Human Rights, the Geneva Conventions, and treaties against torture and genocide - and it unites us with people from every country and culture.
Barack ObamaRead
Many people want the government to protect the consumer. A much more urgent problem is to protect the consumer from the government.
Milton FriedmanRead
I don't know who I am or who I was. I know it less than ever. I do and I don't identify myself with myself. Everything is totally contradictory, but maybe I have remained exactly as I was as a small boy of twelve.
Alberto GiacomettiRead