Man makes holy what he believes as he makes beautiful what he loves.
Ernest RenanRead
None of the miracles with which ancient histories are filled, occurred under scientific conditions. Observation never once contradicted, teaches us that miracles occur only in periods and countries in which they are believed in and before persons disposed to believe in them.
Interpretation
What this quote means
This quote suggests that miracles are culturally and contextually bound to the beliefs of people and do not happen under scientific scrutiny.
Ernest Renan's quote reflects on the nature of miracles and how they are often perceived through the lens of cultural beliefs. He asserts that historical accounts of miraculous events are only valid in contexts where belief in such phenomena is prevalent, implying that scientific observation, which requires skepticism and rationality, does not support the claim of genuine miracles. The idea is that miracles thrive in an atmosphere of faith and are rejected by a rational, scientific approach.
Themes
MiraclesBeliefScienceCultureSkepticism
In practice
Example use cases
This quote could be used in a philosophy class discussion about the intersection of science and religion.
More from Ernest Renan
All quotes →Forgetfulness, and I would even say historical error, are essential in the creation of a nation.
Ernest RenanRead
When people complain of life, it is almost always because they have asked impossible things of it.
Ernest RenanRead
He whom God has touched will always be a being apart: he is, whatever he may do, a stranger among men; he is marked by a sign.
Ernest RenanRead
Let us remember that sorrow alone is the creator of great things.
Ernest RenanRead
The talent of historians lies in their creating a true ensemble out of facts which are but half true.
Ernest RenanRead
Similar quotes
Little thinks, in the field, yon red-cloaked clown, Of thee, from the hill-top looking down; And the heifer, that lows in the upland farm, Far-heard, lows not thine ear to charm; The sexton tolling the bell at noon, Dreams not that great Napoleon Sto
Ralph Waldo EmersonRead
Old age is a tyrant, who forbids, under pain of death, the pleasures of youth.
Francois De La RochefoucauldRead
I thought I was growing wings— it was a cocoon. I thought, now is the time to step into the fire— it was deep water. Eschatology is a word I learned as a child: the study of Last Things; facing my mirror—no longer young, the news—always of death, the dogs—rising from sleep and clamoring and howling, howling.... ("Seeing For a Moment")
Denise LevertovRead
Now I see that all relationships are virtual, even those that take place in person. Whether we use our bodies or a keyboard, it all comes down to two minds crying out from their solitude.
Roger EbertRead
Every one suspects himself of at least one of the cardinal virtues.
F. Scott FitzgeraldRead
I'll believe corporations are people when Texas executes one
Bill MoyersRead