For scholarship - if it is to be scholarship - requires, in addition to liberty, that the truth take precedence over all sectarian interests, including self-interest.
John PolanyiRead
Our assessment of socio-economic worth is largely a sham. We scientists should not lend ourselves to it - though we routinely do. We should, instead, insist on applying the criterion of quality.
Interpretation
What this quote means
The value of scientific work should not be judged solely by economic factors; quality should be the primary criterion.
In this quote, John Polanyi argues that the assessment of the worth of scientific research is often distorted by socio-economic factors, and scientists frequently compromise their integrity by adhering to these assessments. He emphasizes the importance of prioritizing quality over economic value, suggesting that scientific contributions should be evaluated based on their true merit rather than their perceived financial relevance.
Themes
ScienceQualitySocio-EconomicValueIntegrity
In practice
Example use cases
A scientist speaking at a conference about the importance of prioritizing research quality over funding.
More from John Polanyi
All quotes →If we treasure our own experience and regard it as real, we must also treasure other people's experience.
John PolanyiRead
It is this, at its most basic, that makes science a humane pursuit; it acknowledges the commonality of people's experience.
John PolanyiRead
When, as we must often do, we fear science, we really fear ourselves.
John PolanyiRead
Similar quotes
I see Edward Snowden as someone who has chosen, at best, exile from the country he loves-with a serious risk of his assassination by agents of his government or life in prison (in solitary confinement)-to awaken us to the danger of our loss of democracy to a total-surveilla nce state
Daniel EllsbergRead
If we compare a severely defective human infant with a nonhuman animal, a dog or a pig, for example, we will often find the nonhuman to have superior capacities, both actual and potential, for rationality, self-consciousness, communication and anything else that can plausibly be considered morally significant.
Peter SingerRead
Enormous amounts of money are spent for publicity. As a result, large quantities of alimentary and pharmaceutical products, at the least useless, and often harmful, have become a necessity for civilized men.
Alexis CarrelRead
On the night that the Second World war was declared, there were crowds in the street. It was a summer's night and there was a blackout. On every side you heard people crying: 'Look at the moon!' The moon had been there every minute of their lives and they'd never seen it.
Laurens Van Der PostRead
We do not want to be reminded that it is we, the indigenous people, who are poor and exploited in the land of our birth. These are concepts which the Black Consciousness approach wishes to eradicate from the black man's mind before our society is driven to chaos by irresponsible people from Coca-cola and hamburger cultural backgrounds.
Steven BikoRead
Whatever the misery, he could not regain contentment with a world which, once doubted, became absurd.
Sinclair LewisRead