The Great Spirit made all things. He gave the white people a home beyond the great waters. He supplied these grounds with game, and gave them to his red children; and he gave them strength and courage to defend them.
TecumsehRead
Those who call for censorship in the name of the oppressed ought to recognize it is never the oppressed who determine the bounds of censorship.
Interpretation
What this quote means
Censorship often misrepresents the desires of the oppressed, as it is usually imposed by those in power rather than by the marginalized themselves.
In this quote, Aryeh Neier highlights the irony and complexity of censorship when it's justified as a means to protect or empower the oppressed. He suggests that those advocating for censorship often do so not truly representing the oppressed, who may not agree with their restrictions. This calls into question the motivations behind censorship and illustrates that it is typically the powerful who define what is allowed, rather than the oppressed setting the boundaries of their own voices.
Themes
CensorshipOppressionFreedomSpeechPower
In practice
Example use cases
During a seminar on freedom of expression, one could quote Neier to emphasize the importance of understanding who controls the narrative.
Similar quotes
You don't need organized religion to connect with the universe. Often a church is the only place you can go to find peace and quiet... But it shouldn't be confused with connecting with one's spirit.
Alice WalkerRead
Beneath the sophistication of Buddhist psychology lies the simplicity of compassion. We can touch into this compassion whenever the mind is quiet, whenever we allow the heart to open.
Jack KornfieldRead
How horrible it is to have so many people killed! And what a blessing that one cares for none of them!
Jane AustenRead
The Christian faith is the most exciting drama that ever staggered the imagination of man - and the dogma is the drama.
Dorothy L. SayersRead
If on the other hand he went to pay his respects to The Door and it wasn't there . . . what then? The answer, of course, was very simple. He had a whole board of circuits for dealing with exactly this problem, in fact this was the very heart of his function. He would continue to believe in it whatever the facts turned out to be, what else was the meaning of Belief? The Door would still be there, even if the Door was not.
Douglas AdamsRead