Our tools are extensions of our purposes, and so we find it natural to make metaphorical attributions of intentionality to them; but I take it no philosophical ice is cut by such examples.
John SearleRead
Darwin's greatest achievement was to show that the appearance of purpose, planning, teleology (design), and intentionality in the origin and development of human and animal species was entirely an illusion. The illusion could be explained by evolutionary processes that contained no such purpose at all. But the spread of ideas through imitation required the whole apparatus of human consciousness and intentionality
Interpretation
What this quote means
The quote asserts that apparent purpose in evolution is an illusion, explained by natural processes rather than design.
John Searle's quote reflects on the revolutionary impact of Charles Darwin's work, emphasizing that what we perceive as purposeful design in the natural world, including the evolution of species, is actually a product of random evolutionary processes. Searle indicates that while we may attribute intentionality and planning to evolution, these are merely illusions created by our own consciousness. Instead, the spread of ideas and behaviors among humans is influenced by our conscious ability to imitate and create meaning, separate from any inherent purpose in evolution itself.
Themes
EvolutionIllusionPurposeDarwinConsciousness
In practice
Example use cases
In a lecture about the principles of evolution, one might quote Searle to illustrate the complexity of perceived purpose in nature.
More from John Searle
All quotes βWe do not live in several different, or even two different, worlds, a mental world and a physical world, a scientific world and a world of common sense. Rather, there is just one world; it is the world we all live in, and we need to account for how we exist as part of it.
John SearleRead
You can't *discover* that the brain is a digital computer. You can only *interpret* the brain as a digital computer.
John SearleRead
Where conscious subjectivity is concerned, there is no distinction between the observation and the thing observed.
John SearleRead
Similar quotes
The promise of the American Dream requires that we are all provided an equal opportunity to participate in and contribute to our nation.
Charles B. RangelRead
I've always thought that a lot of the problems in the world would be solved if a spaceship did arrive, then anyone with one head and two arms and two legs would be your brother! It wouldn't matter where they were from or what they believed or anything. It might be good for us.
Sigourney WeaverRead
Oh, without prayer what are the church's agencies, but the stretching out of a dead man's arm, or the lifting up of the lid of a blind man's eye? Only when the Holy Spirit comes is there any life and force and power.
Charles SpurgeonRead
I agree that two times two makes four is an excellent thing; but if we are dispensing praise, then two times two makes five is sometimes a most charming little thing as well.
Fyodor DostoevskyRead
"Bombing Afghanistan back into the Stone Age" was quite a favourite headline for some wobbly liberals. The slogan does all the work. But an instant's thought shows that Afghanistan is being, if anything, bombed OUT of the Stone Age.
Christopher HitchensRead
Things like that happen all the time in this great big world of ours. It's like taking a boat out on a beautiful lake on a beautiful day and thinking both the sky and the lake are beautiful. So stop eating yourself up alive. Things will go where they're supposed to go if you just let them take their natural course.
Haruki MurakamiRead