QuoteProject
Identity politics is not politics at all, since it precisely negates the political as such by re-construing political positions in ethnic terms, subsuming 'ought' under 'is.'
Mark Fisher
ShareWTF𝕏

Interpretation

What this quote means

Identity politics distorts traditional political discourse by focusing on ethnic and identity categories rather than broader political principles.

Mark Fisher's quote critiques the concept of identity politics, arguing that it undermines genuine political discourse by framing political issues in terms of ethnic identities. He suggests that this approach reduces political arguments to mere categorizations based on identity, shifting the conversation from discussing what should be done ('ought') to what is currently the case ('is'), thus negating the essence of political debate and action.

Themes

IdentityPoliticsEthnicityDiscoursePower

In practice

Example use cases

During a university lecture on social justice, I might use this quote to provoke discussion on the effectiveness of identity politics in achieving equality.

More from Mark Fisher

Jetsetting is now not the privilege of the elite so much as a veritiginous mundanity for a permanently dispossessed global workforce.
Mark FisherRead
If it is true, for instance, that depression is constituted by low serotonin levels, what still needs to be explained is why particular individuals have low levels of serotonin. This requires a social and political explanation.
Mark FisherRead
The most powerful love songs always turn on the discrepancy between the act of declaring love and the knowledge that the ostensible addressee is no longer there, was never there, and could never be there.
Mark FisherRead
Little Axe's records are wracked with collective grief. Spectral harmonicas resemble howling wolves; echoes linger like wounds that will never heal; the voices of the living harmonise with the voices of the dead in songs thick with reproach, recrimination and the hunger for redemption.
Mark FisherRead
If people dying as a consequence of the implementation of measures cannot count as evidence that the legislation has detrimental effects, what would?
Mark FisherRead
What many students most want from college, although they would never admit it, is an authority structure. There is a demand for an authority which they can then reject; they want to be told what to do, so they can disobey. It is a textbook case of bad faith, a flight from freedom.
Mark FisherRead

Similar quotes

The strong are strengthened by reverses; the trouble is that the true meaning of events scores next to nothing in the match we play with men. Appearances decide our gains or losses and the points are trumpery. And a mere semblance of defeat may hopelessly checkmate us.
Antoine De Saint-ExuperyRead
Heroes rarely look the way we draw them in our minds: attractive, imposing figures with rippling muscles and strong chins. More times than not they are humble beings, small and flawed. It is only their spirits that are beautiful and strong.
Richard Paul EvansRead
If there's good, strong evidence from science that such and such is the case and this is contrary to Buddhism, then we will change.
Dalai LamaRead
I embrace my rival, but only to strangle him.
Jean RacineRead
If he exalts himself, I humble him. If he humbles himself, I exalt him. And I go on contradicting him Until he understands That he is a monster that passes all understanding.
Blaise PascalRead
I hate quotations. Tell me what you know.
Ralph Waldo EmersonRead

A little wisdom, now and then

Subscribe for the occasional hand-picked quote. No noise.