The test of a real comedian is whether you laugh at him before he opens his mouth.
It may be said that artist and censor differ in this wise: that the first is a decent mind in an indecent body and that the second is an indecent mind in a decent body.
Interpretation
What this quote means
Artists express profound ideas through unconventional means, while censors restrict expression based on societal norms.
In this quote, George Jean Nathan contrasts the nature of artists with that of censors. He suggests that artists possess a refined, decent mind but often operate in a world that may not align with their artistic values, thus appearing 'indecent' in their delivery. Conversely, censors, who impose restrictions on artistic expression, are described as having an 'indecent mind,' as their motivations to control and limit creativity stem from less noble intentions, despite presenting themselves as upholdes of decency.
Themes
In practice
Example use cases
This quote can be used during a panel discussion on the role of censorship in art.
More from George Jean Nathan
All quotes →Beauty makes idiots sad and wise men merry.
Bad officials are the ones elected by good citizens who do not vote.
It is the mark of a superior person that, left to themselves they are able endlessly to amuse, interest and entertain themselves out of their personal stock of meditations, ideas, criticisms, memories, philosophy, humor and what not.
Politics is the diversion of trivial men who, when they succeed at it, become important in the eyes of more trivial men.
All that is necessary to raise imbecility into what the mob regards as profundity is to lift it off the floor and put it on a platform.
Similar quotes
My friend George and I were walking on the beach in Norfolk, and there were thousands of [razor-clam] shells. They were so beautiful, I thought I had to do something with them. So, we decided to make [a dress] out of them. . . . The shells had outlived their usefulness on the beach, so we put them to another use on a dress. Then Erin [O’Conner] came out and trashed the dress, so their usefulness was over once again. Kind of like fashion, really.
Sometimes the magnetism of a song is impossible to ignore, and it demands that it be sung in a certain way.
Staring Girl I once knew a girl who would just stand there and stare. At anyone or anything, she seemed not to care She'd stare at the ground, She'd stare at the sky. She'd stare at you for hours, and you'd never know why. But after winning the local staring contest, she finally gave her eyes a well-deserved rest.
Eiffel saw his Tower in the form of a serious object, rational, useful; men return it to him in the form of a great baroque dream which quite naturally touches on the borders of the irrational ... architecture is always dream and function, expression of a utopia and instrument of a convenience.
I am now satisfied that the future music of this country must be founded upon what are called negro melodies. This must be the real foundation of any serious and original school of composition to be developed in the United States.
I'm more interested in melodic things. I think the biggest challenge when you go to play a solo is trying to invent a melody on the spot.