In a constitutional democracy the moral content of law must be given by the morality of the framer or legislator, never by the morality of the judge.
Robert BorkRead
The notion that Congress can change the meaning given a constitutional provision by the Court is subversive of the function of judicial review; and it is not the less so because the Court promises to allow it only when the Constitution is moved to the left.
Interpretation
What this quote means
This quote critiques the idea that Congress can alter the judicial interpretation of the Constitution, suggesting this undermines judicial review.
Robert Bork's quote addresses the tension between legislative power and judicial interpretation within the context of the U.S. Constitution. He argues that if Congress has the ability to redefine constitutional provisions as interpreted by the Court, it threatens the very principle of judicial review. Bork expresses concern over the potential manipulation of constitutional meanings, particularly when such interpretations are aligned with a shift in progressive political ideology, highlighting the necessity for an independent judiciary to uphold constitutional integrity.
Themes
Judicial ReviewConstitutionCongressLawInterpretationPolitics
In practice
Example use cases
This quote can be used in a political debate to emphasize the importance of judicial independence.
More from Robert Bork
All quotes →A society deadened by a smothering network of laws while finding release in moral chaos is not likely to be either happy or stable.
Robert BorkRead
When a judge assumes the power to decide which distinctions made in a statute are legitimate and which are not, he assumes the power to disapprove of any and all legislation, because all legislation makes distinctions
Robert BorkRead
Similar quotes
An honest private man often grows cruel and abandoned when converted into an absolute prince. Give a man power of doing what he pleases with impunity, you extinguish his fear, and consequently overturn in him one of the great pillars of morality.
Joseph AddisonRead
It is only by instigation of the wrongs of men that what are called the Rights of Man become turbulent and dangerous.
James Russell LowellRead
The fact that astronomies change while the stars abide is a true analogy of every realm of human life and thought, religion not least of all. No existent theology can be a final formulation of spiritual truth.
Harry Emerson FosdickRead
February 1997 - National Prayer Breakfast in Washington attended by the President and the First Lady. "What is taking place in America," she said, "is a war against the child. And if we accept that the mother can kill her own child, how can we tell other people not to kill one another."
Mother TeresaRead
A BUSINESSMAN cannot force you to buy his product; if he makes a mistake, He suffers the consequences; if he fails, he takes the loss. _x000D_ A bureaucrat, forces you to obey his decisions, whether you agree with him or not... If he makes a mistake, you suffer the consequences; If he fails, He passes the loss on to you, in the form of heavier taxes.
Ayn RandRead
Once the inner connection is grasped, all theoretical belief in the permanent necessity of existing conditions collapses before their collapse in practice -- Letter to Ludwig Kugelmann (July 11, 1868)
Karl MarxRead