QuoteProject
When poetry separates from song, then the words have to carry all the rhythm themselves; they have to do all the work. They can't rely on the singing voice.
Edward Hirsch
ShareWTF𝕏

Interpretation

What this quote means

Poetry must convey its own rhythm and emotion without the aid of music.

In this quote, Edward Hirsch reflects on the relationship between poetry and song, emphasizing that when poetry stands alone without the support of melody, it becomes essential for the words themselves to generate their own rhythm and emotional resonance. This highlights the power of language and the responsibility of the poet to create a compelling experience purely through text.

Themes

PoetryRhythmLanguageWordsEmotion

In practice

Example use cases

In a literary discussion about the evolution of poetry, one might use this quote to illustrate the shift from musical forms to written expressions.

More from Edward Hirsch

It's absolutely crucial to maintain my life as a poet.
Edward HirschRead
The commitment to working at poetry is important because a poet is a maker, and a poem is a made thing. We have to honor our feelings by working to transform them into something meaningful and lasting.
Edward HirschRead
As far as I'm concerned, freedom is the most important thing to creativity. You should feel free to write in whatever way, whatever language, feels comfortable to you.
Edward HirschRead
The idea that a poem was a made thing stayed with me, and I decided then that I wanted to be an artist, not just a diarist. So I put myself through a kind of apprenticeship in writing poetry, and I understood even then that my practice as a poet was deeply related to my reading.
Edward HirschRead
And every year there is a brief, startling moment _x000D_ When we pause in the middle of a long walk home and _x000D_ Suddenly feel something invisible and weightless _x000D_ Touching our shoulders, sweeping down from the air: _x000D_ It is the autumn wind pressing against our bodies; _x000D_ It is the changing light of fall falling on us.
Edward HirschRead
The idea of a poem as a message in a bottle means that it's sent out towards some future reader, and the reader who opens that bottle becomes the addressee of the literary text.
Edward HirschRead

Similar quotes

Most of the time - in 'Pan's Labyrinth' or 'Devil's Backbone' - I'm talking about my childhood.
Guillermo Del ToroRead
Art is purposiveness without purpose.
Immanuel KantRead
It's difficult because nothing's preordained by plan and you can't control it. That's one of those joys and thrills and nerve-racking realities of being an actor. A lot has to do with luck, no matter what your talent or contribution can be.
Benedict CumberbatchRead
A novel should tell a story, be a pleasure to read, and at the same time it should be thought-provoking, even a bit instructive.
Olga TokarczukRead
Black is the Color and none is the number
Bob DylanRead
If only someone else could paint what I see, it would be marvellous, because then I wouldnt have to paint at all.
Alberto GiacomettiRead

A little wisdom, now and then

Subscribe for the occasional hand-picked quote. No noise.

Quote by Edward Hirsch | QuoteProject