Punditry is like weather forecasting: the winds can shift without warning. I remember when nobody would bet a McDonald's Quarter Pounder that Bill Clinton would win the White House.
James CarvilleRead
I tell my students that the single most powerful thing that we have in this country - something that literally harbors no dissent and no questioning - is the all-powerful elite narrative.
Interpretation
What this quote means
The dominant narrative shapes our beliefs and perspectives, often suppressing dissent and questioning.
In this quote, James Carville emphasizes the influence that a prevailing elite narrative holds over society. He suggests that this narrative is so powerful and accepted that it silences dissent and discourages critical thinking, which can hinder true understanding and progress within the country. Carville's assertion invites reflection on the importance of questioning dominant narratives and being aware of the complexities of the information presented to us.
Themes
NarrativeDissentInfluencePowerSocietyEducation
In practice
Example use cases
In a classroom discussion about media literacy, this quote can be used to highlight the importance of questioning sources.
More from James Carville
All quotes →Over the course of history, governments, political regimes, and leaders have done some stupid things despite all arguments to the contrary, at times even against their own self-interest.
James CarvilleRead
Don't get mad. Don't get even. Just get elected, then get even.
James CarvilleRead
I have people ask me if I'm going to convince my daughters to be Democrats, and I say, 'I have yet to convince my daughters to close a door.' I don't how in the world I would ever convince them to be in a political affiliation.
James CarvilleRead
I used to think that if there was reincarnation, I wanted to come back as the President or the Pope or as a 400 basball hitter. But now I would like to come back as the bond market. You can intimidate everybody.
James CarvilleRead
We say there are people who have worked in campaigns who say that they have lost some - and we call those folks operatives, managers, strategists, consultants; and then there are people who work in campaigns and say that they have never lost, and we call them liars.
James CarvilleRead
Similar quotes
I don't think that our Founders would believe that America could long prosper if the people were not readers.
Ben SasseRead
When you work with kids, especially, you want to be ready to turn the camera on at a moment's notice.
Clint EastwoodRead
...Writings can be stolen, or changed, or used for evil purposes. But isn't the risk worth taking? The more people who share knowledge, the greater safeguard for it. Isn't there more danger in ignorance than knowledge?
Lloyd AlexanderRead
In one sense, the stories I read betrayed me. Too few gave me back my mirror image. Fewer still spoke to, or acknowledged, the existence of the problems I faced as a black foster child from a dysfunctional and badly broken home.
Nikki GrimesRead
Slavery is but half abolished, emancipation is but half completed, while millions of freeman with votes in their hands are left without education.
Robert Charles WinthropRead
It is in fact a part of the function of education to help us escape, not from our own time - for we are bound by that - but from the intellectual and emotional limitations of our time.
T. S. EliotRead