QuoteProject
It is always dishonest for a reviewer to review the author instead of the author's book.
Edward Abbey
ShareWTF𝕏

Interpretation

What this quote means

Reviewing a book should focus on its content, not the author's personal life or character.

Edward Abbey emphasizes the importance of integrity and objectivity in literary criticism. He argues that a review should evaluate the work itself rather than be influenced by preconceived notions about the author, suggesting that critics should judge based solely on the merits of the book and its message.

Themes

ReviewHonestyLiterary CriticismObjectivityIntegrity

In practice

Example use cases

In a discussion about the ethics of book reviews at a literary event.

More from Edward Abbey

Married couples who quarrel bitterly every day may really need each other as deeply as those who appear to be desperately in love.
Edward AbbeyRead
I love America because it is a confused, chaotic mess - and I hope we can keep it this way for at least another thousand years. The permissive society is the free society.
Edward AbbeyRead
If it's knowledge and wisdom you want, then seek out the company of those who do real work for an honest purpose.
Edward AbbeyRead
The earth is real. Only a fool, milking his cow, denies the cow's reality.
Edward AbbeyRead
I believe in nothing that I cannot touch, kiss, embrace.... The rest is only hearsay.
Edward AbbeyRead
Why can't we simply borrow what is useful to us from Buddhism, Hinduism, Taoism, especially Zen, as we borrow from Christianity, science, American Indian traditions and world literature in general, including philosophy, and let the rest go hang? Borrow what we need but rely principally upon our own senses, common sense and daily living experience.
Edward AbbeyRead

Similar quotes

Of all the creatures that man kills for his amusement there is only one that he kills out of hatred—other men. Man hates nothing as much as himself. That is why war is called the leprosy of the human soul.
Halldr LaxnessRead
There is nothing in the world more stubborn than a corpse: you can hit it, you can knock it to pieces, but you cannot convince it.
Alexander HerzenRead
Introspection, or 'sitting in the silence,' is an unscientific way of trying to force apart the mind and senses, tied together by the life force. The contemplative mind, attempting its return to divinity, is constantly dragged back toward the senses by the life currents.
Paramahansa YoganandaRead
I found that things became a lot easier when I no longer expected to win. You abandon your masterpiece and sink into the real masterpiece.
Leonard CohenRead
It's very important to say that French doesn't belong to France and to French people. Now you have very wonderful poets and writers in French who are not French or Algerian - who are from Senegal, from Haiti, from Canada, a lot of parts of the world.
Leila SlimaniRead
Pride is a tricky, glorious, double-edged feeling.
Adrienne RichRead

A little wisdom, now and then

Subscribe for the occasional hand-picked quote. No noise.